The post conquest publicity machine of William the Conqueror had two main objectives. Firstly to create a case in support of William’s claim to the English crown. Secondly, to create a case to discredit Harold Godwinson’s claim and assassinate his character and that of his family.
Master Wace had connections to Bayeux Cathedral and was writing in the 1160’s, a hundred years after the conquest. His sources were post conquest and his patron was Henry II. His Chapter IX on Edward’s death and Harold’s succession immediately follows his account of Harold’s shipwreck in Normandy and his oaths.
Firstly he skips over any explanation of William’s absence from the English court during Edward’s extended illness from the beginning of November 1065 through his illness and the consecration of his cathedral in preparation of his burial.
‘The day came that no man can escape, and king Edward drew near to die. He had it much at heart, that William should have his kingdom, if possible; but he was too far off, and it was too long to tarry for him, and Edward could not defer his hour. He lay in heavy sickness, in the illness whereof he was to die; and he was very weak, for death pressed hard upon him’.
Wace invents a dialogue between Harold and Edward, stating that Harold had primed his followers to support his grab for the throne. Wace tells us by dialogue that Edward has not fathered an heir, and that the people want him to name an heir who will maintain peace, and that they want his successor to be Harold. This does not specify whether Harold has been formally elected by the witan, or whether Edward actually has the authority to name his own successor. Thus he states William’s claim that Edward was coerced by Harold and his followers.
“Then Harold assembled his kindred, and sent for his friends and other people, and entered into the king's chamber, taking with him whomsoever he pleased. An Englishman began to speak first, as Harold had directed him, and said ;
" Sire, we sorrow greatly that we are about to lose thee ; and we are much alarmed, and fear that great trouble may come upon us : yet we cannot lengthen thy life, nor alter thy fate. Each one must die for himself, and none for another; neither can we cure thee; so that thou canst not escape death ; but dust must return to dust. No heir of thine remains who may comfort us after thy death. Thou hast lived long, and art now old, but thou hast had no child, son or daughter; nor hast thou other heir, who may remain instead of thee to protect and guard us, and to become king by lineage. On this account the people weep and cry aloud, and say they are ruined, and that they shall never have peace again if thou failest them. And in this, I trow, they say truly ; for without a king they will have no peace, and a king they cannot have, save through thee.
Give then thy kingdom in thy lifetime to some one who is strong enough to maintain us in peace. God grant that none other than such may be our king ! Wretched is a realm, and little worth, when justice and peace fail ; and he who doth not or cannot maintain them, has little right to the kingdom he hath.
Well hast thou lived, well hast thou done, and well wilt thou do; thou hast ever served God, and wilt be rewarded of him. Behold the best of thy people, the noblest of thy friends ; all are come to beseech thee, and thou must grant their prayer before thou goest hence, or thou wilt not see God. All come to implore thee that Harold may be king of this land. We can give thee no better advice, and no better canst thou do."
As soon as he had named Harold, all the English in the chamber cried out that he said well, and that the king ought to give heed to him. " Sire' they said, "if thou dost it not, we shall never in our lives have peace."
The next part of the dialogue gives Edward’s response as imagined by Wace. It presents William’s claim that he was previously promised the throne by Edward, but not when. It also claims that some Englishmen have sworn to support this, but again, not whom or when. This could be a veiled reference to Harold’s oath.
“Then the king sat up in his bed, and turned his face to the English there, and said, " Seignors, you well know, and have ofttimes heard, that I have given my realm at my death to the duke of Normandy ; and as I have given it, so have some among you sworn that it shall go.”"
Then Harold takes his prompt and requests the throne from Edward.
“But Harold, who stood by, said, " Whatever thou hast heretofore done, sire, consent now that I shall be king, and that your land be mine ; I wish for no other title, and want no one to do any thing more for me.”"
Edward states that Harold will have the throne but the wording carefull avoids Edward saying ‘I give it to you.’ Edward is merely acknowledging his awareness that there is nothing he can do to prevent Harold taking control. He then prophecises that William will successfully take his revenge on Harold.
" Harold," said the king, " thou shalt have it, but I know full well that it will cost thee thy life. If I know any thing of the duke, and the barons that are with him, and the multitude of people that he can command, none but God can avail to save thee."
Harold responds that he does not fear William.
“Then Harold said that he would stand the hazard, and that if the king would do what he asked, he feared no one, be he Norman or other.”
Edward then gives his consent that the English select their own king and by this allows them to make Harold the heir.
“So the king turned round and said, whether of his own free will I know not, "Let the English make either the duke or Harold king as they please, I consent." Thus he made Harold heir to his kingdom, as William could not have it. A kingdom must have a king; without one, in fact, it would be no kingdom ; so he let his barons have their own will.
Wace concludes the scene with Edward’s death and burial.
“And now he could abide no longer. He died, and the English lamented much over him. His body was greatly honoured, and was buried at Westminster ; and the tomb which was made for him was rich, and endureth still.”
Wace finally claims that Harold used his position to take the crown and deliberately concealed his coronation from William.
“As soon as king Edward was dead, Harold, who was rich and powerful, had himself anointed and crowned, and said nought of it to the duke, but took the homage and fealty of the richest, and best born of the land.”
No comments:
Post a Comment